No man, no problem Some assumptions regarding correlation of mass political repressions with mass culture and domestic crime
Main Article Content
Abstract
The article justifies the need for the shift from the metaphysical speculations to the actual scientific exploration of the impact the tragic events of the Soviet past had on the contemporary Ukrainians’ mass psychology and behavior. In the authors’ view, a mandatory intermediate step towards this is to put forward the hypotheses that can be empirically verified. The authors make an attempt to propose a theoretical construct that links mass political repressions in the 30’s of the XX century with the facts of domestic crime in the post-totalitarian societies and samples of modern mass culture. Assassinations performed by common citizens for the sake of solving their life problems are viewed as examples of domestic crime while the TV shows which casually “suggest” that way of solving life problems to the viewers represent mass culture. The authors state a conceptual difference in the attitude to assassination in the showy practices of mass culture and in the classical literature works. They denounce murder as the gravest crime and, at the same time give evidence of the tendency of mass psychology to accept domestic crime as a way to deal with the wear and tear of life. It is assumed that being enrooted in mass psychology, political repressions of the 1930s had a “reverse” destructive influence amplifying and deepening the abovementioned tendency. The authors put forward an idea that inspired by political repressions the transgenerational rooting of domestic crime stereotypes occurs in a direct way (by means of inter-generational channels), on the one hand, and through mass culture, on the other, which is also burdened by psychological consequences of mass political repression. A mental experiment has been conducted, which proved a possibility to operationalize the proposed hypothetical construct and, thus, to verify it empirically.
Downloads
Article Details
References
Horbunova, V. and Klymchuk, V. (2017). Chy varto radity zhyttiu: yakymy ye psykholohichni naslidky Holodomoru v povsiakdennomu zhytti ukraintsiv [Is it worth to be glad about life: what are psychological consequences of olodomor in everyday life of Ukrainians]. Ukraina moloda [Young Ukraine], 8 August (ukr).
Horbunova, V. and Klymchuk, V. (2017). “My mozhemo stavaty plich-o-plich ne lyshe pid chas revolutsii, a i shchodnia” [We can stand side-by-side not only during revolutionary times but every day]. Uriadovyi kurier [Government courier], 27 October (ukr).
Hornostay, P. P. (2012). Kolektyvna travma ta grupova identychnist [Collective trauma and group identity]. Psykholohichni perspektyvy. Spetsialnyi vypusk “Aktualni problemy psykholohii malykh, serednikh ta velykykh grup. Vol. 2. Problema tsilisnosti suspilstva, hrupy ta osobystosti [Psychological perspectives. Special Issue “Actual problems of psychology of small, medium and large groups”. Problem of integrity of society, group and personality], pp. 89–95 (ukr).
Hornostay, P. P. (2014). Kollektivnyye travmy i natsionalnyy kharakter [Collective trauma and national character]. Psykholohichne konsultuvannia i psykhoterapiia [Psychological counselling and psychotherapy], 1-2, 127–137 (rus).
Dostoyevskiy, F. (2001). Prestupleniye i nakazaniye [Crime and punishment]. Moscow: Olimp Publ. (rus).
Zola, E. (1986). Thérèse Raquin; Damskoye schastye: Romany [Thérèse Raquin; Ladies Paradise: Novels]. Kishinev (rus).
Kravchenko, B. (1997). Sotsialni zminy i natsionalna svidomist v Ukraini XX st. [Social change and national conscious in Ukraine in XX century]. Kyiv: Osnovy Publ. (ukr).
Kulchytskyi, S. (2004). Demohrafichni vtraty Ukrainy u XX stolitti [Demographical loss of Ukraine in XX century]. Dzerkalo tyzhnia [Week mirror]. 2-8 October (ukr).
Lashchenko, O. Holodomor yak factor vplyvu na suspilnu psykholohiiu [Holodomor as an impact factor for psychology of society], retrieved at: http://www.radiosvoboda.org (ukr).
Leskov, N. (1981). Ledi Makbet Mtsenskogo uyezda [Lady Macbeth of the Mtsensk District]. Povesti i rasskazy [Novels and short stories]. Moscow: Pravda Publ. (rus).
Mace, J. (2008). Pisliahenotsydne seredovyshche [After-genocide environment]. Den’ i vichnist Dzheimsa Meisa [Day and eternity of James Mace]. Kyiv, pp. 156–157 (ukr).
Naydonova, L. A. (2011). Transheneratsiina peredacha psykholohichnoi travmy holodomoru [Trans-generational transfer of psychological trauma of Holodomor]. Psykholohichni perspektyvy. Spetsialnyi vypusk “Psykholohichni ymiry ukrainskoho sotsiokulturnoho prostoru” [Psychological perspectives. Special Issue “Psychological Dimensions of Ukrainian socio-cultural space”], pp. 3-12 (ukr).
Naydonova, L. A. (2012). Istorychna travma spilnoty: yak nashchadkam pamiataty trahichne? [Historical trauma of community: how successors should remember the tragedy?]. Praktychna psykholohiia ta sotsialna robota [Practical psychology and social work], 2, 48–55 (ukr).
Obushny, M. and Voropayeva, T. (2009). Polityko-psykholohichni aspekty Holodomoru 1932–1933 rokiv [Political and psychological aspects of Holodomor of 1932-1933]. Sotsialna psykholohiia [Social psychology], 2, 39–48 (ukr).
Ohirko, O. (2002). Dukhovno-moralni naslidky holodomoru v Ukraini [Spiritual and moral consequence of Holodomor in Ukraine]. Personal [Personel], 11, 25–27 (ukr).
Bazhan, O. and Podkur, R. (2013). Politychni represii v Ukrainskii RSR 1937–1938: doslidnytski refleksii ta interpretatsii. Do 75-richchia “Velykoho teroru” v SRSR [Political repression in Ukrainian Soviet Republic in 1937–1938: research and interpretation. For 75 years anniversary of “Great Terror” in USSR]. Kyiv: Institute of history of Ukraine (ukr).
Psykholohichni naslidky holodomoru – zanyzhena samootsinka i strakh ukraintsiv pered vladoiu [Psychological consequence of Holodomor – low self-esteem and fear of authority of Ukrainians]. Dzerkalo tyzhnia [Week mirror] (2012). 20 November (ukr).
Stasiv, L. V. (2003). Neobkhidno povernuty i zberehty henetychnu pamiat [We need to get back and preserve genetic memory]. Holodomor 1932–1933 rokiv yak velychezna trahediia ukrainskoho narodu [Holodomor of 1932–1933 as a huge tragedy of Ukrainian nation]. Materials of All-Ukrainian scientific conference, Kyiv (ukr).
Trofimova, N. and Sonyuk, V. (2003). Yaki sotsialno-psykholohichni naslidky Holodomoru? [What are the social and psychological consequences of Holodomor?]. Den’ [Day], 22 November (ukr).
Shakespeare, W. (1986). Makbet [Macbeth]. In William Shekspir, Tvory v shesty tomakh. Tom 5 [William Shakespeare. Works in 6 volumes. Vol. 5]. Kyiv: Dnipro Publ. (ukr).
Shakespeare, W. (1953). Makbet [Macbeth]. In William Shekspir, Izbrannyye proizvedeniya [Selected works]. Moscow (rus).
Shytuyk, M. (2002). Holod – henotsyd 1933 roku: istoryko-politolohichnyi analiz sotsialno-demohrafichnykh ta moralno-psykholohichnykh naslidkiv na terytorii Mykolaivshchyny [Famine-genocide of 1933: historical and political analysis of social-demographic and moral-psychological consequences on the territory of Mykolaiv region]. Mykolaivshchyna: litopys istorychnykh podii [Mykolaiv region: сhronicle of historical events]. Mykolaiv (ukr).